...nameless, unreasoning, unjustified terror which paralyzes. (Of course, these words come from FDR's famous first inauguration speech in 1933.)
I am truly and deeply depressed by the palpable sense of fear that has run through so many of the thoughts, comments, and posts during the last two units of our course. Perhaps the current debate around Bill C-51 and any number of other almost Orwellian things happening at the moment has heightened my sensitivity, but I truly despair for civil liberties and personal freedom of thought at the moment. Then again, it just may be the wild oscillations of the pendulum which inevitably seem to accompany significant social and technological changes and innovations.
I refer, of course, to the great fear--verging on some sort of hysterical moral panic--about the bogeyman of social media and the evils they stand poised to wreak on our (professional) lives. We need to remember that "social media" as we have come to know, love, loathe, and fear them are less than a decade old--Facebook (being abandoned in droves by young people as it becomes the domain of creaky middle-agers), Twitter, Instagram, Tumblr, Vine, and all the others have only existed for a handful of years. Still, they seem to have followed an all-too-familiar trajectory. First, there is the utopian discourse about their astonishing potential to make our lives unimaginably better, empower the dispossessed, speak truth to power, and so forth. And now, we have reached the "cautionary tale", profoundly dystopian phase, in which all we hear are horror stories about how they will destroy our lives. The truth, as always, is not only in between, but probably terribly mundane and boring.
Nevertheless, I am truly and deeply troubled by the fear, paralysis, and aversion they have provoked. Yes, there are indeed idiots out there who happily post and share wildly stupid things--things which may indeed come back to haunt them in some way, shape, or form at some point down the road. (Or they may not. The EU has recently decided that people have the "right to be forgotten" on the internet, and to have Google search results removed--although how this can possibly be implemented is an entirely separate question.) Yes, potential employers and others have become aware of social media and often conduct at least cursory searches of candidates' online existences (although few, if any, employers have developed HR policies or their own professional codes of ethics about this area). But that does not and should not mean that reasonable people become terrified, paralyzed, and--by FAR the worst of all--self-censoring.
Whatever any of us do for a living, we are also human beings--creatures with profound social needs, and persons with ideas, interests, and passions. These may be quotidian things (food, hobbies, etc). But they may also be much more substantial--social, cultural, and political. Personally, I happen to fall into the latter camp. Perhaps because of my former career as a journalist, am am still very interested in, and care deeply about, "current events". I am, today, appalled by the wanton destruction of priceless historical artifacts and manuscripts by ISIS idiots in Mosul. I am also passionate about the FCC decision regarding "net neutrality". I care deeply about the potential implications of Bill C-51. I am infuriated by Alberta's continued reliance on unsustainable non-renewable resource revenue to fund the public purse. I'm also interested in things much more "trivial", like popular culture and whether a dress is white/gold or blue/black.
I have, for several years, posted, shared, tweeted, retweeted, and even sporadically blogged about all kinds of social, cultural, and political things. Sometimes those various activities have included rants, profanity, sarcasm, vitriol, and potentially "inappropriate" comments, humor, and who knows what else. They OFTEN include strong opinions. But they are things I find interesting and/or care about. I don't post naked selfies (or any other kind of selfies, really), drunken stupidity, pictures of cats or food, or mindless platitudes or affirmations. So perhaps I engage in some form of "self-censorship". But I do not--and will not--self-censor my thoughts, nor will I particularly trouble my pretty little head with hopelessly feeble and essentially pointless "privacy settings". (Anybody who is half-decent with computers and who has even the slightest desire to do so can easily circumvent those; and besides, official, pseudo-official, and downright covert state apparatuses are surveilling everything anyway--Hi, NSA spooks!) Could some of my social, cultural, and political personal expression online come back to haunt me? I suppose it's possible, but that's a risk I'm MORE than willing to take. I can rest assured that I am not terribly likely to be offered a job by the Conservative Party of Canada any time soon, but that's more than fine with me, as long as I'm not also hauled off to jail for something I tweeted (which can and does happen in many places around the world).
This is why I found Michelle Clark's TEDx talk particularly depressing and chilling. She, like so many others, has already succumbed to and completely internalized the mistaken belief that we must censor what we say and do online--which is so perilously close to censoring what we say, do, and think offline as well as to be utterly terrifying. THAT is what strikes fear into my heart--the internalized fear that results in self-censorship. We cannot simply succumb to the Thought Police. I don't want this to sound like the demented ravings of a tin-foil-hat wearing conspiracy theorist, but when we become so paranoid that we start to self-censor not only deeds and words but even thoughts, then we have entered a world that is truly frightening.
Thursday, February 26, 2015
Friday, February 6, 2015
And now for something completely different
(Sorry this week's blog is late...I've been battling a bug this week, and just haven't quite been able to keep up!)
This year, I'm thinking of trying something different with a different (higher-level) class. I've compiled a list of 10 songs about consumerism. Their assignment would be to analyze the song and discuss its critique of consumerism. But I'm definitely open to suggestion--about different songs, different approaches to the assignment, etc. So feel free to make suggestions!
And here, for your educational thinking, as well as your viewing and listening pleasure, are the 10 songs I've thought of so far. (Lyrics for all songs are available at musixmatch.)
References:
Duran, C. [Charlie Duran] (2013.06.04). Jonathan Richman - Rockin' Shopping Center [video file]. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hb0KcCIsGkE
Lorde. (2013.05.12). Lorde - Royals [video file]. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LFasFq4GJYM
Alexm799. (2009.03.15). The Clash - Lost in the Supermarket [video file]. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qsrEAWcAvRg
DaveClark5Hits. (2009.11.24). Rolling Stones: "Satisfaction!" [video file]. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HoxRFOr_sQ0
Chaine de DiapoRetro. (2012.03.10). Janis Joplin-Mercedes Benz(original) [video file]. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qev-i9-VKlY
DivisionIsTheNWO. (2010.08.20). BILLY BRAGG - The Busy Girl Buys Beauty (lyric-italiano) [video file]. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=45m98bGBoy8
AllModConsTheJam's channel. (2011.11.24). The Jam - Shopping [video file]. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oXnX1AKUqXU
laurynhillvevo. (2013.10.04). Ms. Lauryn Hill - Consumerism (Pseudo Video) [video file]. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mFPhKf_dg7g
emimusic. (2009.02.28). The Verve - Bitter Sweet Symphony [video file]. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1lyu1KKwC74
billyjoelVEVO. (2013.04.09). Billy Joel - Movin' Out (Anthony's Song) (Audio) [video file]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJtL8vWNZ4o
Musixmatch - The world's largest lyrics catalog. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.musixmatch.com/
Thursday, January 29, 2015
Synchronous Spontaneous Serendipitous Synchronicity
As I sit down to write this asynchronous blog entry fairly late on a Thursday evening, I have just returned home from teaching one of my classes. It's a group of 8 "advanced" adult ESL learners. This was the end of the first week of classes, so we have not yet begun to delve into the meat of the course. I had them work in teams to label the provinces and territories of Canada and name the capital cities of the various jurisdictions. That part of the activity was fairly banal, although they had fun and learned something by doing it.
But the really interesting things happened after they were done. We started discussing what they know about various parts of the country. This quickly led to discussion about landscapes, which in turn veered into a discussion about urban and rural life. In discussing cities, we started talking about homelessness. This led to a discussion around substance abuse. And that led to a fascinating discussion of Vancouver's Insite safe injection clinic--initiated by one of the students. We also had a discussion about Canada's treatment of First Nations people, again initiated by a student. These were amazing discussions, with huge amounts of learning taking place, and none of the flow from topic to topic was initiated or directed by me, the ostensible teacher.
So a seemingly "simple" cartographic exercise led to numerous real, authentic, relevant, meaningful discussions about a range of subjects. The learners were able to use and extend their speaking and listening skills. They met new vocabulary. They used a variety of grammatical constructions. They became so engaged in what we were talking about that they became less self-conscious about making mistakes and simply talked--about things that mattered to them. For an ESL instructor, this is pure gold--and it's precisely the sort of thing that could never happen in online learning, be it synchronous or asynchronous.
Granted, the circumstances or context were quite specific--adults, advanced learners, a fairly small group of people who are comfortable with each other, and so on. But I have done this activity several times, with learners at various levels of English proficiency, in groups both larger and smaller, and the result is always the same. The activity leads to spontaneous conversations. The topics vary--but they are always meaningful. The students exchange ideas and opinions as best they can. They encounter things they didn't know--both subject matter and linguistic.
I was about to say that ESL may be a "special" circumstance, but I remembered that the paper by Ge (Ge, 2012) about asynchronous vs. blended cyber learning dealt with ESL students, so clearly ESL is not a special case. Online or distance learning simply cannot--as of yet--replicate the sort of spontaneous interpersonal exchanges I have just described. And more often than not, these kinds of exchanges have, through the magic of serendipity or synchronicity, been discussions I have been able to relate directly to the lesson/unit/topic we are "supposed to be" doing, according to the curriculum and syllabus.
The fact that I can do the work I need to for this course at 22:30 on a Thursday night is fantastic. It's an incredible convenience, and if not for asynchronous online delivery, I might well not be able to do this course or the program of which it is a component. That said, there is simply no way that, given current technology capabilities, any mode of online delivery could possibly reproduce the incredible, spontaneous dialogue that took place in my class tonight. Perhaps someday the technology will exist to allow such things, but at the moment it simply does not, and online learning is always frustratingly attenuated and mediated. Online learning is great in many ways, don't get me wrong; but as far as I am concerned, it is still a fairly pale shadow of the kinds of learning that can take place in a face-to-face environment.
Reference: Ge, Z.-G. (2012). Cyber Asynchronous versus Blended Cyber Approach in Distance English Learning. Educational Technology & Society, 15(2), 286-297.
But the really interesting things happened after they were done. We started discussing what they know about various parts of the country. This quickly led to discussion about landscapes, which in turn veered into a discussion about urban and rural life. In discussing cities, we started talking about homelessness. This led to a discussion around substance abuse. And that led to a fascinating discussion of Vancouver's Insite safe injection clinic--initiated by one of the students. We also had a discussion about Canada's treatment of First Nations people, again initiated by a student. These were amazing discussions, with huge amounts of learning taking place, and none of the flow from topic to topic was initiated or directed by me, the ostensible teacher.
So a seemingly "simple" cartographic exercise led to numerous real, authentic, relevant, meaningful discussions about a range of subjects. The learners were able to use and extend their speaking and listening skills. They met new vocabulary. They used a variety of grammatical constructions. They became so engaged in what we were talking about that they became less self-conscious about making mistakes and simply talked--about things that mattered to them. For an ESL instructor, this is pure gold--and it's precisely the sort of thing that could never happen in online learning, be it synchronous or asynchronous.
Granted, the circumstances or context were quite specific--adults, advanced learners, a fairly small group of people who are comfortable with each other, and so on. But I have done this activity several times, with learners at various levels of English proficiency, in groups both larger and smaller, and the result is always the same. The activity leads to spontaneous conversations. The topics vary--but they are always meaningful. The students exchange ideas and opinions as best they can. They encounter things they didn't know--both subject matter and linguistic.
I was about to say that ESL may be a "special" circumstance, but I remembered that the paper by Ge (Ge, 2012) about asynchronous vs. blended cyber learning dealt with ESL students, so clearly ESL is not a special case. Online or distance learning simply cannot--as of yet--replicate the sort of spontaneous interpersonal exchanges I have just described. And more often than not, these kinds of exchanges have, through the magic of serendipity or synchronicity, been discussions I have been able to relate directly to the lesson/unit/topic we are "supposed to be" doing, according to the curriculum and syllabus.
The fact that I can do the work I need to for this course at 22:30 on a Thursday night is fantastic. It's an incredible convenience, and if not for asynchronous online delivery, I might well not be able to do this course or the program of which it is a component. That said, there is simply no way that, given current technology capabilities, any mode of online delivery could possibly reproduce the incredible, spontaneous dialogue that took place in my class tonight. Perhaps someday the technology will exist to allow such things, but at the moment it simply does not, and online learning is always frustratingly attenuated and mediated. Online learning is great in many ways, don't get me wrong; but as far as I am concerned, it is still a fairly pale shadow of the kinds of learning that can take place in a face-to-face environment.
Reference: Ge, Z.-G. (2012). Cyber Asynchronous versus Blended Cyber Approach in Distance English Learning. Educational Technology & Society, 15(2), 286-297.
Thursday, January 22, 2015
Copyright, Copyleft, Copywrong
In one of those serendipitous moments, I happened to have a quick look at my Facebook page as I sat down to write this week's blog entry. Lo and behold, there was a post from Boing Boing about copyright in the EU.
The post leads to this article, written by Cory Doctorow, a founder of Boing Boing, among monay other things. Doctorow is a Toronto native who has become one of the leading voices of the Open Rights and Creative Commons movements. He recently published a book entitled "Information Doesn't Want to Be Free: Laws for the Internet Age", which examines the current state of global copyright laws, especially as they pertain to creative/artistic production and consumption.
The interesting thing about the Boing Boing article, of course, is the fact that the one and only currently elected member of the Pirate Party, Julia Reda of Germany, is leading the European Parliamentary review of copyright legislation in Europe! The Pirate Party was born in Sweden in response to government crackdowns and raids on the file-sharing site The Pirate Bay. It has since spread internationally, including to Canada (disclosure: I have donated to the Pirate Party of Canada).
Tangentially, The Pirate Bay was again raided and shut down just last month, but as a countdown timer on The Pirate Bay homepage hints, it might be back in operation again soon. In any event, to have a member of parliament representing a party founded by so-called "pirates" who have been hounded and prosecuted for years leading the review of copyright legislation is truly remarkable.
Just this week, the organization Copyright for Creativity issued a manifesto calling for comprehensive copyright reform to "support creativity and innovation". This and all of the above are just some examples of recent developments in the world of copyright.
The point of all this is that copyright and "intellectual property" are incredibly hotly-contested concepts at the moment. There are a great many other voices in the discussions, including politicians, academics, cultural creators, and so on. The people, articles, ideas, and debates I have referenced in this post may seem far removed from the world of an individual teacher in Alberta. But I would propose that they are not at all distant. These discussions will shape the flow of ideas in the world we inhabit. As far as I'm concerned, these are profoundly important ideas, and--if we are to call ourselves informed citizens, let alone educators--it is our responsibility to at least become informed about these debates. At appropriate grade levels, we should also be introducing these debates to our students. They must be aware of, and understand at some level, these sorts of discussions if they are to be informed, engaged, critical "digital citizens".
References:
Copyright for Creativity. (n.d.). Retrieved 2015-01-22 from http://copyright4creativity.eu/
Doctorow, C. (2015.01.22). They put a Pirate Party MEP in charge of EU copyright reform: you won't believe the awesomesauce that followed. Retrieved 2015.01.22 from http://boingboing.net/2015/01/22/they-put-a-pirate-party-mep-in.html
Gibbs, S. (2015-01-21). Countdown Timers Hints at Pirate Bay Return. Retrieved 2015-01-22 from http://thepiratebay.se/
Gibbs, S. (2014-12-10). Swedish Police Raid Sinks The Pirate Bay. Retrieved 2015-01-22 from http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/dec/10/swedish-police-raid-pirate-bay
Information Doesn't Want to Be Free. (n.d.). Retrieved 2015.01.22 from http://store.mcsweeneys.net/products/information-doesn-t-want-to-be-free
Pirate Party of Canada. (n.d.). Retrieved 2015-01-22 from https://www.pirateparty.ca/
The Copyright Manifesto. (n.d.). Retrieved 2015-01-22 from http://copyright4creativity.eu/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/C4C-Copyright-Manifesto-20150119.pdf
The Pirate Bay. (n.d.). Retrieved 2015-01-22 from http://thepiratebay.se/
Post by Boing Boing.
The post leads to this article, written by Cory Doctorow, a founder of Boing Boing, among monay other things. Doctorow is a Toronto native who has become one of the leading voices of the Open Rights and Creative Commons movements. He recently published a book entitled "Information Doesn't Want to Be Free: Laws for the Internet Age", which examines the current state of global copyright laws, especially as they pertain to creative/artistic production and consumption.
The interesting thing about the Boing Boing article, of course, is the fact that the one and only currently elected member of the Pirate Party, Julia Reda of Germany, is leading the European Parliamentary review of copyright legislation in Europe! The Pirate Party was born in Sweden in response to government crackdowns and raids on the file-sharing site The Pirate Bay. It has since spread internationally, including to Canada (disclosure: I have donated to the Pirate Party of Canada).
Tangentially, The Pirate Bay was again raided and shut down just last month, but as a countdown timer on The Pirate Bay homepage hints, it might be back in operation again soon. In any event, to have a member of parliament representing a party founded by so-called "pirates" who have been hounded and prosecuted for years leading the review of copyright legislation is truly remarkable.
Just this week, the organization Copyright for Creativity issued a manifesto calling for comprehensive copyright reform to "support creativity and innovation". This and all of the above are just some examples of recent developments in the world of copyright.
The point of all this is that copyright and "intellectual property" are incredibly hotly-contested concepts at the moment. There are a great many other voices in the discussions, including politicians, academics, cultural creators, and so on. The people, articles, ideas, and debates I have referenced in this post may seem far removed from the world of an individual teacher in Alberta. But I would propose that they are not at all distant. These discussions will shape the flow of ideas in the world we inhabit. As far as I'm concerned, these are profoundly important ideas, and--if we are to call ourselves informed citizens, let alone educators--it is our responsibility to at least become informed about these debates. At appropriate grade levels, we should also be introducing these debates to our students. They must be aware of, and understand at some level, these sorts of discussions if they are to be informed, engaged, critical "digital citizens".
References:
Copyright for Creativity. (n.d.). Retrieved 2015-01-22 from http://copyright4creativity.eu/
Doctorow, C. (2015.01.22). They put a Pirate Party MEP in charge of EU copyright reform: you won't believe the awesomesauce that followed. Retrieved 2015.01.22 from http://boingboing.net/2015/01/22/they-put-a-pirate-party-mep-in.html
Gibbs, S. (2015-01-21). Countdown Timers Hints at Pirate Bay Return. Retrieved 2015-01-22 from http://thepiratebay.se/
Gibbs, S. (2014-12-10). Swedish Police Raid Sinks The Pirate Bay. Retrieved 2015-01-22 from http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/dec/10/swedish-police-raid-pirate-bay
Information Doesn't Want to Be Free. (n.d.). Retrieved 2015.01.22 from http://store.mcsweeneys.net/products/information-doesn-t-want-to-be-free
Pirate Party of Canada. (n.d.). Retrieved 2015-01-22 from https://www.pirateparty.ca/
The Copyright Manifesto. (n.d.). Retrieved 2015-01-22 from http://copyright4creativity.eu/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/C4C-Copyright-Manifesto-20150119.pdf
The Pirate Bay. (n.d.). Retrieved 2015-01-22 from http://thepiratebay.se/
Thursday, January 15, 2015
One life, Two Lives, Three Lives, Four...
Five potato, six potato, seven potato, more.
Of this week's readings and viewing material (PLEASE don't get me started on what I thought of the Cyberwise YouTube clip!), I found Ohler's brief paper the most substantive, meaningful, and thought provoking (Ohler, 2011). (There's something to be said for brevity--a lesson I need to learn!) His notion that students lead multiple digital lives and his argument for "character education" is quite cogent--even though some may find the idea of "character education" rather reactionary.
He is perhaps somewhat unfair to teachers, administrators, specialists, and school boards. Most by now certainly understand that "studying issues related to the personal, social, and environmental effects of a technological lifestyle" do indeed have a place in school. But I'm not sure that many would (yet) agree with his assertion that "the most important job before us as a society is to help our students understand issues of digital responsibility, and to do so at school as part of a digital health initiative."
Personally, I'm inclined to agree with Ohler. As most of you know, my epiphany from our last course was that we have been thinking about the relationship between "school" and "technology" the wrong way around. It's now beating a dead horse to say that "school" as a social institution is still mired in 19th (let alone 20th) century ideas and values, while "technology" is a revolutionary paradigm which is fundamentally changing every aspect of civilization, of which "school" is just one small part.
As such, rather than thinking about how to "integrate" (and often bend, fold, spindle, and mutilate in our dogged efforts) technology into a broken paradigm of "school", we should be thinking in precisely the opposite way--how do we completely reconceptualize school and integrate it within the new technological paradigm?
In such a different approach, studying issues related to the personal, social, and environmental effects of a technological lifestyle, and "helping our digital kids balance the individual empowerment of digital technology with a sense of personal, community, and global responsibility" do indeed come to occupy a central position.
It seems to me that Ohler is quite correct when he suggests that (many) educators (still) tend to respond to sexting, cyberbullying, and other technology-related issues--both good and bad--in a piecemeal, ad hoc fashion, as if they are unrelated. I see evidence of the same sort of thing when I see how educators are trying (with the best possible intentions) to "integrate" technology into whatever part of education with which they are involved.
The problem is precisely a failure to think about technology holistically and systemically. To use a building analogy, it's like making a building airtight (in a valiant attempt to conserve energy), without realizing the impacts this has on air quality, moisture, mold, and other unintended consequences. It's a failure to understand the building holistically and systemically.
My final thought has to do with the notion of multiple lives or identities. Even if/when schools do see the importance of studying a technological lifestyle, students still lead multiple lives and create multiple identities. We all do. Our "digital selves" are constructs. We--all of us--carefully construct, manage, mediate, and curate our online identities. My own children were already well versed in this by age 7 or 8 as they created "identities" and "avatars" for Minecraft and other online games and interactions. In some cases, they created multiple personas for the same platform, using them interchangeably to manifest different "personalities" online.
So when we speak of "digital citizenship", it seems to me that we must always be aware of the fact that--unlike "being ourselves", so much of which we cannot control or change, in "real" life--our online "selves" are always deliberately constructed, artificial, mediated presences. "Michael Ireton" on Twitter or (shudder!) Facebook is not the same as "Michael Ireton" in this online world, and not the same again as "Michael Ireton" in real life. (Not to mention alternate online personalities I may or may not have created.)
As one of the participants in Burnett's study (Burnett, 2011) said of her online persona, "It's like it's me but it's a bit more of me."
It is deeply naive to think there is a direct one-to-one relationship between who we are offline and "who we are" (possibly plural) online.
References:
Ohler, J. (2011). Digital Citizenship Means Character Education for the Digital Age. Kappa Delta Pi Record, 48(1), 25-27
Burnett, C. (2011). Pre-service teachers' digital literacy practices: exploring contingency in identity and digital literacy in and out of educational contexts. Language and Education, 25(5), 433-449.
Of this week's readings and viewing material (PLEASE don't get me started on what I thought of the Cyberwise YouTube clip!), I found Ohler's brief paper the most substantive, meaningful, and thought provoking (Ohler, 2011). (There's something to be said for brevity--a lesson I need to learn!) His notion that students lead multiple digital lives and his argument for "character education" is quite cogent--even though some may find the idea of "character education" rather reactionary.
He is perhaps somewhat unfair to teachers, administrators, specialists, and school boards. Most by now certainly understand that "studying issues related to the personal, social, and environmental effects of a technological lifestyle" do indeed have a place in school. But I'm not sure that many would (yet) agree with his assertion that "the most important job before us as a society is to help our students understand issues of digital responsibility, and to do so at school as part of a digital health initiative."
Personally, I'm inclined to agree with Ohler. As most of you know, my epiphany from our last course was that we have been thinking about the relationship between "school" and "technology" the wrong way around. It's now beating a dead horse to say that "school" as a social institution is still mired in 19th (let alone 20th) century ideas and values, while "technology" is a revolutionary paradigm which is fundamentally changing every aspect of civilization, of which "school" is just one small part.
As such, rather than thinking about how to "integrate" (and often bend, fold, spindle, and mutilate in our dogged efforts) technology into a broken paradigm of "school", we should be thinking in precisely the opposite way--how do we completely reconceptualize school and integrate it within the new technological paradigm?
In such a different approach, studying issues related to the personal, social, and environmental effects of a technological lifestyle, and "helping our digital kids balance the individual empowerment of digital technology with a sense of personal, community, and global responsibility" do indeed come to occupy a central position.
It seems to me that Ohler is quite correct when he suggests that (many) educators (still) tend to respond to sexting, cyberbullying, and other technology-related issues--both good and bad--in a piecemeal, ad hoc fashion, as if they are unrelated. I see evidence of the same sort of thing when I see how educators are trying (with the best possible intentions) to "integrate" technology into whatever part of education with which they are involved.
The problem is precisely a failure to think about technology holistically and systemically. To use a building analogy, it's like making a building airtight (in a valiant attempt to conserve energy), without realizing the impacts this has on air quality, moisture, mold, and other unintended consequences. It's a failure to understand the building holistically and systemically.
My final thought has to do with the notion of multiple lives or identities. Even if/when schools do see the importance of studying a technological lifestyle, students still lead multiple lives and create multiple identities. We all do. Our "digital selves" are constructs. We--all of us--carefully construct, manage, mediate, and curate our online identities. My own children were already well versed in this by age 7 or 8 as they created "identities" and "avatars" for Minecraft and other online games and interactions. In some cases, they created multiple personas for the same platform, using them interchangeably to manifest different "personalities" online.
So when we speak of "digital citizenship", it seems to me that we must always be aware of the fact that--unlike "being ourselves", so much of which we cannot control or change, in "real" life--our online "selves" are always deliberately constructed, artificial, mediated presences. "Michael Ireton" on Twitter or (shudder!) Facebook is not the same as "Michael Ireton" in this online world, and not the same again as "Michael Ireton" in real life. (Not to mention alternate online personalities I may or may not have created.)
As one of the participants in Burnett's study (Burnett, 2011) said of her online persona, "It's like it's me but it's a bit more of me."
It is deeply naive to think there is a direct one-to-one relationship between who we are offline and "who we are" (possibly plural) online.
References:
Ohler, J. (2011). Digital Citizenship Means Character Education for the Digital Age. Kappa Delta Pi Record, 48(1), 25-27
Burnett, C. (2011). Pre-service teachers' digital literacy practices: exploring contingency in identity and digital literacy in and out of educational contexts. Language and Education, 25(5), 433-449.
Sunday, November 30, 2014
Big Rock (Beer? Candy Mountain? Yes to both, please!)
To be perfectly honest, this course has been a complete blur. I started a new job as an ESL instructor just as the course began. I have found myself constantly scrambling just to try to barely keep pace with everything as we have gone along. This has been an incredibly frustrating experience for me, because I vastly prefer to be completely on top of things.
In a way, this experience is a metaphor for everything we have been reading, doing, and thinking about. In the same way that the course has presented huge streams of data, seeming to move at an incredible pace, so goes the world of "integrating educational technology". The pace of change--in educational theory, technological development, and everything surrounding them--is dizzying. The sheer volume of information is daunting, and growing exponentially. Links lead to more links, and a person can get overwhelmed rather quickly!
Meanwhile, we've been doing all of this through a brand-new platform (D2L, replacing Blackboard) within an environment which didn't even exist a few short years ago (online education). So we've been functioning "within" technology, even as we have been discussing its place and role in education. We have experienced both the power and shortcomings/limitations of this mode of learning as it is presently understood and constructed.
Furthermore, we've dabbled with a few other forms of technology--not the least of them being these blogs themselves. I have mixed feelings about the use of blogs as "technological tools in education". These feelings come both from this experience as well as my own efforts to "use" them as a teacher. First, blogging is generally thought of as a personal undertaking. There seems to be something "forced" and "unnatural" about "using" them as educational tools--especially when they are to be written more formally (with citations, etc) than personally/naturally. Second, this "artificial" use of blogs seems to fail where blogs are supposed to succeed--i.e., in their "interactivity".
Both here and with my own attempts to use blogs as a tool, I have found that the "dialogue" blogs theoretically encourage doesn't really materialize. When people choose to read, follow, and comment on blogs because of personal interest, the dialogue/conversation happens naturally and organically. When people are required to write and respond to blogs, the process is artificial, and loses the very naturalness and authenticity that defines the medium. Even though I have my students do personal writing, it is still an artificially-created entity, and invariably falls flat.
We have also dabbled with Twitter. I have already written extensively about some of my thoughts with respect to this undertaking. What I have just written about blogging also holds true for my thoughts and experiences with the Twitter project. But even more than that, I have found that I have had one other significant issue. Twitter is, by definition and practice, a "social" medium. It is a platform which I have previously used purely for personal, recreational interaction. Again, forcing it to become a "work-related" platform has been a frustrating experience.
At first, I tried to integrate it into my "normal" Twitter account. I found that so unsatisfactory that I felt compelled to create a separate "work" account. But logging into and using it was "work". I found that I deeply resented this intrusion into a medium which had previously been purely for fun. This made me think of a much bigger issue--the "creep" of work into every moment of our lives. We are all now constantly "on the clock". We check our work email--and often end up working as a result--at all hours of day and night. This is disturbing and unacceptable. We cannot allow "work" to permeate our entire existences. There are times and places (both physical and virtual) which must remain sacrosanct.
Ultimately, then, I have mixed feelings about "integrating educational technology". Perhaps it boils down to a matter of design or intended use. Technology which is designed or intended to be "educational" or used for educational purposes (LinoIt being a great example) functions beautifully. But attempts to fold, bend, or mutilate technology which was not designed or intended for education seem much less successful. It is laudable that educators are trying to be creative and interested in technology. But where I find educators sometimes rather overeager and somewhat naive is in the area of the "philosophy of technology"--understanding technology from the inside out; understanding how its design is both intentional and limiting.
I have absolutely no doubt whatsoever that "technology" is driving a revolution at least as massive as the invention of the printing press and the Industrial Revolution. The technological revolution has profound impacts for absolutely every aspect of society--including education. Everyone involved with education--academics, policy makers, administrators, teachers, and all other stakeholders--must do everything humanly possible to truly understand the technological revolution and ensure that the education system is fully integrated within it.
And that is my final point and "takeaway" from this course. So far, we have it backwards. It is not a matter of integrating technology into education, but rather one of integrating education into technology--into an entirely new social paradigm. Rather than trying to shoehorn bits and pieces of technology into the world of education as we know it, we need to imagine an entirely new world of education, and how it can integrate seamlessly within the technological revolution.
Sunday, November 23, 2014
More thoughts about Twitter
Yesterday (November 22), there was a two-page article in the Globe and Mail about Twitter. The company's new goal is to become a major player in the world of "big data". As the article says, "every Twitter user is a data geyser". There's not a word about educational use of the platform--or any of the other supposed social benefits of Twitter (the apocryphal "role" it has supposedly played in the "Arab Spring" and so on). Twitter sees users as nothing more or less than data points/streams to be commodified.
Twitter has always thought of itself--and tried to function--as a "global water cooler"; the place where you talk about your favorite TV show, sports team, and so on. It still seems to function as such, but Twitter apparently faces a growing divergence between veteran, "hard-core" users and their more recent, casual counterparts. Such a bifurcation doesn't bode well for Twitter as a "conversational" medium. It suggests that it may well become more of broadcast/consumption platform, in which most users are passive consumers of content produced by a small minority of producers, with Twitter as the classic middleman or "entrepreneur" (from the French for "enterprise", but more specifically "entre" (between) + "preneur" (getter)--the classic bourgeois middleman inserting himself between producer and consumer), making money by selling users (and their data) to advertisers.
Twitter now has a clearly defined business model, which is unmistakably moving away from individual users and toward advertisers and developers. This would suggest that senior leadership at Twitter cares not a single iota about the social and interpersonal aspects of the medium. Senior leadership isn't interested in how people use Twitter. They make absolutely no mention of the supposed human dimension of the medium--be it social, political, educational, or anything else. They're not interested in the functionality of the platform. All they're interested in is mining and selling data.
To me, this suggests that Twitter is anything but socially conscious. In fact, it is quite the contrary--yet another threat to personal privacy--if such a notion even exists or matters any more. Every time anyone uses Twitter--no matter what they may THINK they're using it for, they are simply becoming a more and more accurately refined data point/stream, to be packaged and sold.
Twitter has always thought of itself--and tried to function--as a "global water cooler"; the place where you talk about your favorite TV show, sports team, and so on. It still seems to function as such, but Twitter apparently faces a growing divergence between veteran, "hard-core" users and their more recent, casual counterparts. Such a bifurcation doesn't bode well for Twitter as a "conversational" medium. It suggests that it may well become more of broadcast/consumption platform, in which most users are passive consumers of content produced by a small minority of producers, with Twitter as the classic middleman or "entrepreneur" (from the French for "enterprise", but more specifically "entre" (between) + "preneur" (getter)--the classic bourgeois middleman inserting himself between producer and consumer), making money by selling users (and their data) to advertisers.
Twitter now has a clearly defined business model, which is unmistakably moving away from individual users and toward advertisers and developers. This would suggest that senior leadership at Twitter cares not a single iota about the social and interpersonal aspects of the medium. Senior leadership isn't interested in how people use Twitter. They make absolutely no mention of the supposed human dimension of the medium--be it social, political, educational, or anything else. They're not interested in the functionality of the platform. All they're interested in is mining and selling data.
To me, this suggests that Twitter is anything but socially conscious. In fact, it is quite the contrary--yet another threat to personal privacy--if such a notion even exists or matters any more. Every time anyone uses Twitter--no matter what they may THINK they're using it for, they are simply becoming a more and more accurately refined data point/stream, to be packaged and sold.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)